| George Long |
1914 |
| Lew Vreeland |
1914 - 1916 / 1922 - 1923 |
| William Hart |
1917 - 1919 |
| Joseph McMahon |
1916 - 1917 / 1919 - 1922 |
| John Schineller |
1923 - 1926 / 1933 - 1939 / 1941 - 1942 |
| William Wells |
1926 - 1929 |
| Ira Stevens |
1929 - 1931 |
| Oscar Mead |
1931 - 1933 / 1942 - 1943 |
| Maurice Welch |
1939 - 1941 |
| Dewey Head |
1943 - 1946 |
| Vernon Barret |
1946 - 1966 |
| Robert Foote |
1966 - 1967 |
| Howard Beach |
1967 |
| Kurt Beger |
1967 - 1969 / 1972 - 1974 |
| James Farrell |
1969 - 1970 |
| Wayne Barr |
1974 - 1975 |
| Stanley Deck |
1975 - 1976 |
| Richard Armistead |
1976 - 1978 |
| Thomas Carey |
1978 - 1980 / 1984 |
| Vicent Roberto Jr. |
1981 - 1982 |
| James Doyle |
1983 |
| Frido Goerlich |
1985 - 1986 |
| Michael Bergin |
1987 - 1988 |
| James Ciulla |
1991 |
| Frank Gunn |
1993 - 1994 |
| Stan Prymylski |
1995 |
| Richard Pottberg |
1996 - 1997 |
| Dale Smith |
1998 - 1999 |
| Edward J. Scott |
2000 - 2001 |
| Charles J. Lewis |
2002 - 2003 |
| Steven S Storino |
2004 - 2005 |
| Drew Kinash |
2006 - 2007 |
